Legal Theory - JURD7223
Faculty: Faculty of Law
School: Faculty of Law
Course Outline: See below
Campus: Kensington Campus
Career: Postgraduate
Units of Credit: 6
EFTSL: 0.12500 (more info)
Indicative Contact Hours per Week: 4
Enrolment Requirements:
Pre-requisite: 24 UOC completed in LLB courses or 24 UOC completed in Juris Doctor courses. Juris Doctor students who commenced prior to 2013 need no pre-requisites.
Equivalent: JURD7431, LAWS2320, LAWS3331
Excluded: JURD7431, LAWS2320, LAWS3331
CSS Contribution Charge: 3 (more info)
Tuition Fee: See Tuition Fee Schedule
Further Information: See Class Timetable
View course information for previous years.
Description
The course sees law as a phenomenon which may usefully be investigated from viewpoints other than those of the practitioner. It critically discusses a number of basic notions associated with contemporary legal philosophy, including the nature of legal analysis, the separation of law from other areas of social life, the character of legal positivism, the role of the legal decision-maker, legal practice as an interpretive activity, the character of moral judgment, the difference in moral theory between the right and the good, liberalism as a political theory and its opponents, and liberalism's attitude to rights and to cultural difference. The course then applies some of these ideas to a number of 'problems' in contemporary legal practice, which vary from semester to semester. They may include human rights in East Asia, the legal response to cultural diversity, feminism and difference, legal responsibility, punishment, rights and judicial power, citizenship, and the character of legal decision-making.
Course Learning Outcomes
- Demonstrate awareness of principles of legal theory and their relationship to the broader context;
- Engage in critical analysis of social and legal institutions;
- Engage in critical analysis of the law on one hand and personal and public morality on the other;
- Produce scholarly writing that demonstrates: (1) acquaintance with the vocabulary of philosophical reflection on law; (2) analysis, synthesis, critical judgment, reflection and evaluation; and (3) cites a range of practical and scholarly interdisciplinary research sources;
- Demonstrate effective oral communication skills by discussing and debating course concepts in a scholarly, reflective and respectful manner; and
- Demonstrate self-management through self-assessment of capabilities and performance and use of previous feedback received in the course.
Topics
- Introduction - law's autonomy
- Weber on modernity and law
- Holmes
- Hart
- Dworkin
- Positivism reassessed
- Legal decision-making
- Approaches to legal judgment
- Morals - the difference between ancients and moderns
- Kant
- Ethics of care
- Morality and ethical life Politics - liberalism
- Individualism
- The communitarian critique
- Liberalism and difference
- The universality of rights
- Legal analysis
- Historical injustice
- Law and Multiculturalism
- Law and the nation state, responsibility to outsiders
- Law and the supervision of mental illness
- The feminist critique of law
- Law and religion
Assessment
Class participation - 20% (maximisable)
Texts